eBay’s paranoid rampage against digital goods accelerated today with the Indian and Italian sites both announcing bans of the products - with twists.
India’s ban announcement says it comes into force on 18 April, but excludes website domain names and tickets (presumably all types) that can be transferred electronically - some good news for the holiday & travel markets, especially the airline ticket bucket shops?
India also announced today, that they are rolling the same “Punishing Sellers’ Accounts with Dumb Idea of the Year” policy that I blogged eBay US and Oz announced earlier in the week.
The Italian ban on digital items is effective immediately, and both the announcement and the linked policy page are prominently displaying the Centurion’s whip. However, the policy page is interesting. It states (emphasis added by me) -
Examples of items that can not be put up for sale on eBay:
- MP3 files copied from a CD purchased or obtained from a recording made during a concert at which the seller was involved;
- EBook if the seller does not own the copyright or is not an authorized dealer;
- Music purchased through iTunes;
- Films copied from a DVD purchased;
- Video games copied from the original CD ROM;
- PDF files of a handbook on a product if the seller is not the copyright owner or an authorized reseller;
- Data and information related to online games such as characters, accounts, currencies and objects.
Examples of items that may be put up for sale on eBay:
- MP3 files of songs written and recorded by the seller (in which the seller owns the rights);
- EBook of recipes written by the vendor;
- Films made by the seller and the seller owns the rights;
- Software developed by the seller and the seller owns the rights;
- Software put on sale by an authorized reseller of software that has the rights for online delivery;
- A digital photo of the Golden Gate taken by the seller;
- A t-shirt imprinted with a photo of a protagonist of a game online.
The Italian announcement and policy page makes no reference to the need to provide the digital goods in a physical format such as on CD or DVD, which is the workaround recommended by eBay US, Canada & Oz.
So far, eBay US & Canada are the only other sites (that have made announcements) that have given sellers a legal workaround for selling digital goods in downloadable format - list them in the classifieds section - apart from Italy specifying certain goods that will continue to be permitted. Italy’s policy is by far the most lenient and seller-friendly. The UK, Singapore, Spain, India, and OZ have all implemented complete bans. Italy is the only EU site that appears to be trying to apply common sense to market preservation.
I haven’t yet seen announcements from any of the other eBay national sites, but expect them to roll in before month end. The lobbyists for the physically disabled homeworkers, who were so vocal immediately after the first US announcement have gone very quiet on the eBay forums, and it can only be assumed they have taken their wares to other sites, which as eBay continually fail to see, reduces the pool of buyers for the remaining die-hard sellers.
Ed.